The Giant 25-Pound Candle
Two gallons of wax and a commitment.
Gifts / By recipient
You married into this family. Now they get to live with your taste.
In-law gifts are a diplomatic exercise. Go too safe and you're forgettable. Go too far and you're a story at every family dinner, forever.
Aim for things for the house that are only slightly wrong. Meat-patterned hand towels for the guest bathroom. Rubber chicken ornaments for a tree that used to be tasteful. A banana slicer for a kitchen that already owns knives.
A prank gift box is the smart choice if you're unsure: it looks like a terrible gift for a few seconds, then reveals the nice one you actually bought. You get the laugh and keep the goodwill.
Two gallons of wax and a commitment.