Stories

Why fake gift boxes work so well

An empty box printed with a ridiculous product turned into a Shark Tank pitch and a holiday staple. The secret is the double reveal.

Bad Gifts editors Β· 2026-11-05

This story contains links to stores. We may earn a commission if you buy through them. How we make money.

A box that looks like it holds something awful. Inside, the real present. It's a simple idea, and it's been a hit for years.

Where they came from

Prank-O, a Minneapolis comedy company, makes empty gift boxes printed with convincing packaging for fake products. The company says it was on Shark Tank in 2018, where Mark Cuban made an offer, and it keeps launching new designs each holiday season. The boxes are now sold at its own site, on Amazon and in mainstream stores.

Why they work: two reveals for the price of one

Most gag gifts have one moment: the unwrap. A fake box has two. First comes the horror of seeing the fake product. Then comes the relief of finding the real gift inside. The second laugh is warmer than the first, and that's why these rarely backfire.

They also solve a real problem: making a boring gift exciting. Socks become an event when the box says they're something much worse.

How to use them well

  • Put something genuinely nice inside. The contrast is the joke.
  • Match the fake product to the person. The closer to "plausible," the bigger the laugh.
  • Film the reveal, with permission. These are some of the most shareable moments of the holidays.

More stories