Stories

The banana slicer, the wolf shirt and the giant knife: how reviewers turned bad products into legends

Three ordinary products became internet folklore without a marketing budget. Here's what happened, and what it says about why we love terrible things.

Bad Gifts editors Β· 2026-11-10

This story contains links to stores. We may earn a commission if you buy through them. How we make money.

Most products die quietly. A few get adopted by the internet and live forever as jokes. Three of them have something in common: nobody behind them set out to be funny. The customers did that.

The Three Wolf Moon shirt

It started with a T-shirt from The Mountain, a New Hampshire apparel company, printed with three wolves howling at a full moon. In 2009 a law student wrote a deadpan Amazon review claiming the shirt had mystical powers, and others piled on. The Wikipedia entry is a good summary of how it spread. The shirt is still sold today.

The Hutzler 571 Banana Slicer

A yellow plastic tool that slices a banana in one press. Reasonable enough. But in late 2009 a Boing Boing post linked to it, and the review section turned into a collaborative comedy project. Know Your Meme's write-up notes thousands of reviews by 2013. Hutzler itself played along on social media.

The slicer works, by the way. That's part of the joke: it solves a problem nobody had, and does it perfectly.

The Wenger 16999 "Giant"

Wenger built a Swiss Army knife with 87 implements and 141 functions to show off a century of tool design. It's roughly as wide as it is long, and it cost a fortune. Reviewers responded the only reasonable way: by describing the tools they'd found inside it, including several that do not exist. InsideHook's history of the trolling is a fun read.

Why this keeps happening

All three share a pattern. Each product is completely sincere, a little too specific, and slightly absurd once you stare at it. Earnestness is what makes them funny. A product that's trying to be a joke rarely becomes one.

That's also the test we use for this site. The best bad gifts aren't cynical. They're sincere objects that become hilarious in the wrong hands, like a banana slicer given to someone with a perfectly good knife.

More stories